Beizaras and Levickas v. Lithuania  | 2020

It started with a kiss: Facebook post leads to hate speech and incitement to violence

We hope that maybe some lonely person, who is being condemned by others, will see this photograph and will no longer feel lonely.

Pijus Beizaras 

Pijus and Mangirdas

In December 2014 Pijus Beizaras used Facebook to announce his relationship with Mangirdas Levickas. The post was public and included a photograph of the couple kissing. At the time, Pijus was a secondary-school student, while Mangirdas was a theology student at Vytautas Magnus University. 

The post went viral, receiving more than 2,400 "likes", and more than 800 comments. Some were supportive, but many spewed homophobic hatred at the couple, with some threatening Pijus and Mangirdas directly. "Satan, please allow me to smash their heads into a wall," said one. Other comments called the couple vile names and even suggested they be "exterminated", burned, or sent to gas chambers and crematoriums. 

Initial proceedings

A complaint was lodged with the Prosecutor General’s, asking for the initiation of proceedings for incitement to hatred and violence. But the prosecutor decided not to commence such proceedings, considering that the comments on Facebook had been just "expressing their opinion". 

The Lithuanian courts endorsed this position, ruling that the behaviour of the young men in posting the photograph had been "eccentric" and provocative. They spoke of Lithuanian "family values" and suggested that the photograph should have been restricted to "like-minded people". The implications were that the Lithuanian authorities themselves did not approve of Pijus and Mangirdas being in a relationship.

 

The findings of the European Court of Human Rights

The Court found discrimination, both in the online hate directed at the couple, and in the failure of the authorities to investigate whether the comments made on the post had constituted incitement to hatred and violence. 

Not only had the couple been discriminated against, but they had been denied any possibility of an effective remedy via the authorities and legal system in their own country. The Court observed that all of the thirty or so pre-trial investigations regarding homophobic hate speech that had been opened in Lithuania between 2012 and 2015, none went to trial. 

Even acknowledging that between 2012 and 2015 some thirty pre-trial investigations regarding homophobic hate speech were opened in Lithuania, one cannot overlook the fact that all of them were discontinued.

Judgment of the European Court of Human Rights, May 2020

Protecting against hate speech in Lithuania

Lithuania has strengthened the investigation and prosecution of homophobic hate speech, issuing new guidance and specialised arrangements for law-enforcement authorities. The country’s domestic case-law has also developed to provide more effective protection against such offences, and it has taken measures to facilitate the reporting and detection of online hate speech. 

Themes:

İlgili örnekler

Eşcinsel çiftler medeni birliktelik kurma hakkı kazandılar

Grigoris Vallianatos ve Nikolaos Mylonas’ın, eşcinsel bir çift olarak, Yunan yasası uyarınca, evlilikten farklı bir resmi beraberlik biçimi olan medeni birliktelik kurmaları engellenmişti. Avrupa İnsan Hakları Mahkemesi bunun ayrımcı bir uygulama olduğuna karar verdi. Yunanistan bu karara karşılık olarak eşcinsel çiftlere medeni birliktelik kurma hakkı tanıyan yeni bir yasa geçirdi.

Read more

Sağlık sigortası tarafından reddedilen eşcinsel çift ayrımcılık davasını kazandı

P.B. ve J.S., J.S.’nin devlet memuru sağlık sigortası programından müşterek yararlanmak istediler ama P.B.’nin talebi kendisi eşcinsel bir partner olduğu için reddedildi. Avrupa mahkemesi Avusturya’nın P.B. ve J.S.’ye devlet memuru sigorta poliçesi kanunu eşcinsel ve karşı cinsten çiftler arasında ayrım yapmayacak şekilde değiştirildiği ana kadar haksız yere ayrımcılık yaptığına hükmetti.

Read more

Bir şahsın mücadelesi sonucunda İrlanda’da eşcinselliğin yasal hale gelmesi

David Norris cinselliğini açıkça ifade etmesinin hakkında ceza kovuşturmasıyla sonuçlanacağını anladıktan sonra panik atakları geçirmeye, yoğun depresyona girmeye başladı. Strazburg Mahkemesi, Norris’in cinselliğinin suç sayılmasının temel haklarını ihlal ettiğine hükmetti. Bu durum 1993’te karşılıklı rıza gösteren yetişkinler arasında eşcinsel eylemlerin İrlanda yasalarına göre tamamen yasal...

Read more