Back

Failure to investigate death of a disabled man in police custody leads to reforms

Jasinskis v. Latvia  | 2010

Failure to investigate death of a disabled man in police custody leads to reforms

Background

Valdis Jasinskis was deaf and mute. He was outside a student party when he was pushed and fell down some stairs. When police attended the scene they were told of his disability, that he had lost consciousness after hitting his head against the ground and that an ambulance was on its way.

However, the police took Mr Jasinskis to a police station. Believing him to be drunk, they put him in a sobering-up cell. Mr Jasinskis knocked on the doors and walls of his cell for some time before going to sleep. However, he could not communicate with police officers because none of them understood sign language and they had taken his notepad away.

Seven hours after Mr Jasinskis had been taken into custody, officers tried but failed to wake him up. Another seven hours later, an ambulance was called to bring him to hospital – but the crew refused to take him, as they thought he was “faking” his condition.

Valdis Jasinskis was eventually taken to hospital a number of hours later, but died shortly afterwards.

Valdis’ father Aleksandrs Jasinskis took the case to the European Court of Human Rights.

Judgment of the European Court of Human Rights

Despite being told about Mr Jasinskis’ fall and his disability, the police had not called for medical attention when he was first detained, or arranged for a way for him to communicate with them. They had also let seven hours pass between failing to revive him and calling an ambulance. In these circumstances, police officers had failed in their duty to safeguard Valdis Jasinskis’ life whilst he was in their care.

The authorities also failed to properly investigate the incident. The initial inquiry was repeatedly passed between different authorities, resulting in significant delays. It was eventually carried out by the same police department which had detained Mr Jasinskis, meaning that it had not been independent.

Though an investigation had later been carried out by an independent bureau, it only started 18 months after the incident – meaning that witnesses’ memories had faded, the scenes could not be examined and the pathologist could not be questioned. Moreover, no effort was made to investigate particular shortcomings in the police officers’ actions.

In these circumstances, the court ruled that Mr Jasinskis’right to life had been violated.

Follow-up

The Latvian authorities have taken a number of steps to make sure that police actions can be effectively and independently investigated.

  • In 2010 and 2011 the Prosecutor General issued decrees strengthening the prosecutorial supervision over alleged offences by police officers.
  • In 2011 a booklet on the complaint mechanism concerning actions or omissions of the police officers was published by the State Police in cooperation with NGOs.
  • In 2012 the Cabinet of Ministers decided to institutionally separate the Internal Security Office from the State Police and transfer it under the supervision of the Minister of the Interior. This meant greater independence for investigations into police actions.  

Reforms in this area are still being monitored by the Council of Europe’s Committee of Ministers.


Related examples

Deadly attack on woman and her son leads to ongoing reforms to combat domestic violence

Elisaveta Talpis’s husband physically abused her for years. She complained to the police, but they took no action for months. One night Elisaveta’s husband attacked her with a knife, wounding her and killing her son when he tried to intervene. The European court condemned the police’s inaction, leading to reforms to address domestic violence in Italy.

Read more

Court win for victims of the Beslan school terrorism attack

In September 2004, over 330 people were killed (including over 180 children) and 750 injured in the Beslan hostage crisis. The authorities had had enough information to know that there would be an upcoming terrorist attack, but had not increased security or warned the public. Due to this shortcoming and others, the European Court ruled that the authorities had failed to properly protect the...

Read more

Parents win fight for justice following their son’s death

Gregor Šilih was 20 when he died in hospital. His parents believed that medical negligence was to blame. They launched legal proceedings to find out the truth. Thirteen years later their claim had still not been resolved. The European court ruled that the authorities had failed to take effective steps to discover the truth. The case led to reforms to prevent the same thing from happening again.

Read more

Justice for the mother of two murdered children

Dana Kontrová repeatedly warned the police that her husband was violent and unstable. One day the police failed to take action after being told the man was threatening his family with a shotgun. Two days later he murdered his children before committing suicide. The European court ruled that the authorities had failed in their duty to protect the children, violating the right to life.

Read more

Reform of gun laws after police shoot dead unarmed men

Two 21-year-olds absconded from military service and went to see their grandmother. When military police arrived, the men were unarmed and non-violent - and tried to run away. Nevertheless, they were shot dead. The Strasbourg court ruled that the military police had used grossly excessive force. This case, and others, led to changes in the rules on the authorities’ use of firearms.

Read more

Death of an alleged victim of human trafficking

At age 20, Oxana Rantseva was allegedly trafficked from Russia to Cyprus for sexual exploitation. Two weeks later, she was found dead beneath a balcony after trying to escape. The Strasbourg court found that the authorities had failed to protect her and also failed to properly investigate after her death. Following the events, a series of measures were carried out to fight human trafficking.

Read more

15-year-old boy stabbed to death outside a school after authorities failed to act

The director of a school asked for the police to be present outside his school gates, due to significant problems between young people. No help was provided. 15 year-old Sedat Kayak was stabbed to death by another student just outside the school. The European court ruled that the authorities had failed in their duty to protect children. The case led to a series of reforms to help prevent school...

Read more

Death of a detainee leads to changes to medical practices in prison

A young man suffering from psychosis and depression was imprisoned for theft. Whilst in jail, he committed suicide. The Strasbourg court ruled that the authorities had not done enough to protect his life. New rules were set up to help prison staff prevent inmates committing suicide.

Read more

"Totally insufficient" investigation of a suspicious death and the reform of criminal investigations

Tatiana Trufin’s brother was killed in suspicious circumstances. Despite evidence of an attack, the authorities did very little to investigate for the next 12 years. The Strasbourg court ruled that their efforts had been totally insufficient. This influenced reforms to improve the effectiveness of criminal investigations in Romania.

Read more