Talpis v. Italy | 2017

Deadly attack on woman and her son leads to ongoing reforms to combat domestic violence

We presented this appeal to the Strasbourg court because in this woman’s story there are all the elements of repeated violence: serious and above all undervalued and unrecognized…

Ms Carrano, one of the lawyers of Ms Talpis, as reported by Corriere della Sera - © Photo Messagero Veneto

Background

Elisaveta Talpis suffered years of domestic violence at the hands of her alcoholic husband. He attacked her on numerous occasions, causing injuries to her head and body. He also tried to make her have sex with his friends by threatening her with a knife. After Elisaveta was hospitalised, she moved into a shelter for three months – but she had to leave due to a lack of space and resources.

Elisaveta tried to tell the authorities about her situation several times. She lodged a formal complaint, asking for prompt action to protect her and her children. However, the police did nothing for months. This created a situation of impunity conducive to further acts of violence.

One evening in November 2013, Elisaveta again contacted the authorities about her husband. Police stopped him and found that he was in a drunken state but allowed him to go home. He went to the house in a rage, attacking Elisaveta with a knife. Her 19-year-old son tried to stop him. The husband stabbed the boy, who died of his injuries. Elisaveta was also stabbed several times in the chest as she tried to escape, but she survived the attack.

Judgment of the European Court of Human Rights

The court ruled that the authorities had failed to take steps to protect Elisaveta and her son given their knowledge of her husband’s violent conduct and the immediate threat he posed. The authorities had also failed to take any steps to investigate her complaints for an excessively long time.

By underestimating the seriousness of the domestic violence, the authorities had allowed a situation to develop where it was being carried out with impunity. These failings had been discriminatory, as they were linked to the fact that the violence was being carried out against a woman in the home.

Evidence showed that many woman in Italy were being murdered by their partners or former partners and that society at large continued to tolerate acts of domestic violence.

The Court reiterates that in domestic violence cases perpetrators’ rights cannot supersede victims’ human rights . . . the State has a positive obligation to take preventive operational measures to protect an individual whose life is at risk.

Judgment of the European Court of Human Rights, March 2017

Follow-up

Elisaveta Talpis was awarded €30,000 in compensation.

In 2013 a law established emergency provisions against gender violence. After these events, Italy brought into force the Council of Europe’s “Istanbul Convention” on violence against women and domestic violence.

Between 2015 and 2018 a series of additional reforms were carried out, including:

Legal changes to strengthen the rights of victims of domestic violence;
Life imprisonment for the murder of a spouse or partner;
Training of police and judges about how to combat domestic and gender-based violence;
A wide range of public events and national campaigns to raise awareness of the issue;
A 24-hour phone line and specialist support units for victims;
An action plan to combat domestic violence from 2017-2020, with substantial financial resources.

Following these reforms, the number of convictions has increased, and the length of criminal proceedings is decreasing. However, the Council of Europe continues to monitor the issue of domestic violence in Italy, whilst further evidence is gathered about the effectiveness of the reforms.

Additional information

Themes:

Related examples

Death of an alleged victim of human trafficking

At age 20, Oxana Rantseva was allegedly trafficked from Russia to Cyprus for sexual exploitation. Two weeks later, she was found dead beneath a balcony after trying to escape. The European court found that the authorities had failed to protect her and also failed to properly investigate after her death. Following the events, a series of measures were carried out to fight human trafficking.

Themes: Right to life Freedom from slavery and human trafficking

Cyprus

Russian Federation*

Reform of gun laws after police shoot dead unarmed men

Two 21-year-olds absconded from military service and went to see their grandmother. When military police arrived, the men were unarmed and non-violent - and tried to run away. Nevertheless, they were shot dead. The European court ruled that the military police had used grossly excessive force. This case, and others, led to changes in the rules on the authorities’ use of firearms.

Themes: Right to equality and freedom from discrimination Right to life

Bulgaria

Failure to investigate death of a disabled man in police custody leads to reforms

Valdis Jasinskis was deaf and mute. He fell down some stairs outside a party and banged his head. The police were told about his injury and his disability, but they locked him in a cell and ignored his attempts to communicate. Mr Jasinskis later died in hospital, and the incident was not properly investigated. This led to a series of measures to help make sure that the police can be properly...

Themes: Right to life

Latvia

Impact of the European Convention on Human Rights