Mennesson v. France |2014

France recognises family ties of parents of surrogate children

We are very happy that our daughters now have their rights and their family ties fully recognised.

Dominique and Sylvie Mennesson, quoted as part of a statement by C.L.A.R.A. in RFI



Dominique and Sylvie Mennesson were unable to conceive a child naturally. Surrogacy arrangements are banned in France, so the couple decided to enter into an agreement in the United States, where the process is legal. 

The surrogate mother gave birth to twin girls—Valentina and Fiorella. 

Dominique and Sylvie were legally recorded as the twins’ parents on their US birth certificates. But when they tried to have the details transferred into France's register of births, the French authorities refused to comply, instead contacting prosecutors. 

The charges were ultimately dropped. But the couple were forced to go through over a decade of legal battles in the French courts concerning the validity of their daughters’ birth records. 

Valentina and Fiorella grew up in legal uncertainty. Their parents complained of difficulties when registering for social security, enrolling the children at the school canteen or an outdoor centre, or when applying for family allowances. 

The twins were also denied French nationality, complicating family travel and raising concerns over their right to remain in France when they became adults. 

Judgment of the European Court of Human Rights

The European court found France’s refusal to recognise the details of Valentina and Fiorella’s US birth certificates undermined their identity within French society and violated their right to a private life.  


France changed its case law in 2015 to recognise the parental ties which unite a French father with a child born abroad through a surrogacy arrangement. 

Since 2013, French nationality certificates must be issued when parental ties can be established through a valid foreign civil status certificate. 

An individual review procedure was also set up, so the Mennesson family were able to have their family ties recognised in France's civil registry and French nationality certificates were issued to Valentina and Fiorella.


Related examples

Woman’s legal fight to find out about her origins

Anita Godelli was abandoned at birth. She tried for decades to find out about her origins, but Italian law prevented her from accessing the information. The European Court of Human Rights ruled that this was unfair and in violation of Anita’s rights. As a result of the European court’s judgment, Anita was finally able to learn the identity of her birth mother.

Read more

Ban lifted on medically assisted reproduction for healthy carriers of serious genetic diseases

As healthy carriers of a serious genetic disease, Rosetta Costa and Walter Pavan were unable to undergo medically assisted reproduction under Italian law. The European court ruled that the law in this area was inconsistent, and in breach of the couple’s rights. This judgment led Italy to lift the ban, which means couples like Rosetta and Walter can now access the treatment they need.

Read more