Local and Regional Democracy and Good Governance

 

Achievements: Transfrontier Co-operation
 

 
Aims

The Council of Europe aims at improving and facilitating transfrontier co-operation in its member states through:

- confidence-building measures to increase tolerance, understanding and good-neighbourly relations between populations;

- provision of legal advice on draft legislation on cross-border co-operation;

- assistance towards the setting up of transfrontier co-operation bodies to ensure that transfrontier relations are sustained and improved.

Activities

The LR-CT (Committee of Experts on Transfrontier Co-operation) was until December 2007 the Council of Europe Committee responsible for activities in Transfrontier Co-operation. Its terms of reference were taken over by the LR-GI Committee in 2008, and then the LR-IC Committee in 2009.

In its years in service, the LR-CT adopted an approach to its work, which included information and data collection, standard setting, dissemination and implementation, measuring the impact and drawing lessons.

For instance, a survey of the legal framework for crossborder co-operation in member states led to the identification of a number of obstacles and difficulties that local authorities have to overcome in order to engage in effective crossborder co-operation. This information enabled the Committee to draw up a “check list” of measures to be taken by local and central authorities in the field of crossborder co-operation. This in turn was transformed into a legal instrument, recommendation Rec(2005)2 of the Committee of Ministers, for dissemination, translation and implemention among the member states.

A further example is provided by work carried out in the framework of the assistance activities programme. The spreading of transfrontier co-operation bodies (“Euroregions”) led to increased demands for legal assistance and the clear identification of the rules applicable at domestic and international level. This was confirmed by the same survey that identified good practices and obstacles to crossborder co-operation. The LR-CT then came to the conclusion that the drafting of a legal instrument was appropriate and agreed to examine a new draft convention – firstly a Uniform law and now, after thorough discussions, a draft third protocol to the Madrid Outline Convention. The work is reaching completion.

Finally, assistance activities revealed that the different languages spoken in the neighbouring countries may be a serious hindrance to crossborder co-operation. The LR-CT decided to study this issue, commissioned a report to a leading specialist, discussed its findings and agreed to draft a legal instrument which became Recommendation Rec(2005)3 on neighbouring languages in border regions. This recommendation is available in several languages and its impact was discussed at an international event held in Trieste, Italy, in December 2005, with the participation of experts from Italy, Austria, Slovenia and Croatia.
The same assistance activities made it possible for the Council of Europe to contribute to the identification of major issues which required the sustained attention of the international community. Examples include the SWOT analysis of crossborder co-operation between states in South-eastern Europe, the case of Kaliningrad, the external border of the enlarged European Union.

In all these cases, the Council of Europe developed the appropriate partnerships or let other Organisations play a constructive role in the management of the issues: the Stability Pact, the Central European Initiative, the OSCE and the European Union.

Since 2005, the Council of Europe has concentrated on the promotion of existing conventions (the MOC and its protocols) and the development of new standards (draft Third protocol). In this connection it should be stressed that the LR-CT innovated insofar as it agreed that informal consultation be held with experts from the capitals on the new draft convention, in order to discuss informally and in smaller, regional compositions, the main features of the draft and the possible difficulties of member states. This working method has proved very effective so far.

The LR-CT also took up the work where the Committee of Ministers had left it after the Chisinau Political Declaration, calling on SEE states to discuss proposals for co-operation and possible international agreements between themselves. This work led to the drafting of two regional treaties, which were given political support by the Skopje Ministerial Conference, and subsequently endorsed by the Committee of Ministers as Recommendation Rec(2007)5 on the conclusion of transfrontier co-operation agreements in South-Eastern Europe.